Book Review: Endless Cities (Phaidon)

Jul. 10, 2008
Google plus Linkedin Pinterest

Cities are like organized religion: richly layered, often paradoxical and uniquely qualified to bring out the best and worst in humankind. A new book edited by Ricky Burdett and Deyan Sudjic and titled The Endless City (Phaidon) conveys the oft-contradictory nature of cities, including their innate ability to both quell and incite social and political conflict.
At least, that's the salutary subtext of the book. It's more arrant objective is to lend fire and brimstone urgency to the sharp rise in the world's urban population within the past century. Even its blazing orange cover, inscribed with eye-popping statistics (like the one estimating 75% of the world's population will live in cities by 2050) is used to convey the apocalyptic urgency of its appeal.
 The Endless City is the culmination of a series of international conferences held by the Urban Age Project, a multidisciplinary investigation into the future of the world's cities lead by the London School of Economics and Deutsche Bank's Alfred Herrhausen Society. The opening line, "in the beginning was the city," sets the tone for the strange blend of religious reference and Darwinian positivism that pervades the introductory chapters. Here the problems native to cities that rapid population growth is likely to exacerbate are outlined, as well as some of the new dilemmas facing today's cities. The authors assure us that in the continuing rise of the urban population leaves us no choice but construct a new archetype for the modern city. That the foundations for this new paradigm rarely stray from the popular canons of urban planning – most notably the writings of Jane Jacobs -doesn't seem to perturb them. In fact they continuously avow their debt to the late great urbanist.
 Laying the groundwork of this discourse is a series of essays exploring the genetic makeup and growth patterns of six world cities -  London, New York, Shanghai, Mexico City, Johannesburg and Berlin. These seek to illustrate both the measures planners and policy makers have taken to deal with issues like housing shortages, escalating crime, public transport etc and the potential of these cities to accommodate future growth.

 Though these essays offer some savory insights into some of the world's most fascinating cities, the kernal of the book lies in the section curtly titled "Issues." A variety of authors (including architect celebrities like Rem Koolhas, Jacques Herzog and Pierre de Meuron) have contributed essays that address various aspects of the urban experience.
The best of these demonstrate how cities can constantly be inscribed with new meanings and rituals, either by investing new meaning into timeless truths, such as Richard Sennett's "The Open City," or like Sophie Body-Gendrot's "Confronting Fear" forge credible connections between the contemporary urban experience and the pressing political and social concerns of our age.  The worst examples treat cities as agglomerations of issues without a human face and to make matters worse are weighed down with indecipherable academic jargon.
 Despite the fact that some salient issues are touched upon, such as the real and imagined threat of terrorism, the shrinking middle class and the growing strain on the world's natural resources there are a couple of remarkable omissions. One is the city's role as a platform for religious harmony and dispute, which in the light of events of the past seven years is an unpardonable oversight. Another is the way technological developments have affected the demands we make of public space, and the extent to which actual public space competes with virtual space - especially for the younger generation.
 However the dreariest section of the book is the one devoted to interventions that illustrate successful policy-making and/or planning. The majority of the examples are so obscure and modest one craves the heroic gestures of past epochs – however misguided or heavy-handed their intent.
 Ultimately, though, Endless Cities represents a valiant effort to turn an impending crisis to our advantage. We can even forgive the authors for the occasional lapse into hyperbole.  The book avoids the obvious pitfall of drawing rudimentary parallels between the various cities visited, and in fact celebrates the endless paradoxes the city represents. After all like religion it's partly this ability to contain contradictions that represents a city's greatest strength and ensures its survival.


Would white supremacists, neo-Nazis and the Ku Klux Klan pose the same threat they do now if a mainstream Republican were president instead of Donald Trump?

Getting poll results. Please wait...