Wye Oak's "The Knot": Still Stunning

Jul. 20, 2009
Google plus Linkedin Pinterest

The Knot, the second album from the Baltimore indie-rock duo Wye Oak, bowled me over on first listen last month, and subsequent weeks have only affirmed my initial impression. I still think it could be the group's breakthrough record, but it now seems that breakthrough might be a delayed one: Today, in an almost apologetic review, Pitchfork writer Mike Powell damned the record with a dismissive 5.9 rating, which is frosty enough to deter a lot of bloggers and music writers from even giving the album the cursory listen it deserves. That's a major setback.

Powell's complaint with the album, as I understand it, is essentially that The Knot is a heavier, more guitar-oriented album than its hushed predecessor, If Childrenwhich, of course, is exactly why I think this new record is so striking. If Children was pleasant if not a little too twee, but the turbulent, slash and burn guitars on The Knot add real stakes to The Knot's sad songsit also helps that Jenn Wasner's blandly pretty voice has grown bolder and more devastating, too.

Don't let one review from one critic who prefers the band be more sweet than sour discourage you from checking out this great record.


The U.S. Supreme Court announced that it will hear the case to determine if Wisconsin Republicans’ redistricting maps are too partisan. Do you believe the U.S. Supreme Court will order Wisconsin to redraw our legislative maps so the majority of legislative districts are competitive and voters will actually have a real choice between a Democrat and Republican?

Getting poll results. Please wait...